In reviewing articles for either for the research project or for publication the criteria are: the topic, research question, the study group, and the readability of the statistical aspect of the research. The research project select to be review is: The Effectiveness of Out-o-School-Time Strategies in Assisting Low-Achieving Students in Reading and Mathematics: A Research Synthesis.
The authors of the research synthesis searched for published and unpublished researches that were conducted after 1984 which addressed to success of the strategy. The groups of interest are the low-achieving or at-risk K-12 students, the measurement of student achievement in reading and/or mathematics which had control/comparison groups. In order for the research to be included it was coded and the characteristics of the Out-of-School-Time (OST) strategy and the students the research addresses, design of the research and methods, data analyses and findings and the quality of the research in the degree of four types of validity. The research studies were the analyzed concluded using meta-analyses that were supplemented with narrative descriptions. Results with then analyzed to see if the moderators influenced the effectiveness of OST strategies.
At first the search found a total 1,271 citations which were then narrowed down to 371 studies. In using the above mentioned methods the studies were narrowed to 56. There were 47 that had reading outcomes, 33 with mathematics outcomes and 24 that addressed both the reading and mathematics outcomes. The moderators of the studies included timeframe, grade level of the students, focus of the OST activities, duration of the OST program, and the type of groupings of the students. The moderators also include research quality, publication and the score type.
This synthesis is the third annual report that Mid-continent Research for Education and Learning (McREL). McREL does research in the area of leadership area of standards-based educational practice. This year’s synthesis focus is on the two areas that most schools worry about is reading and mathematics. The McREL’s emphasis and NCLB’s requirement concerning the quality of research, meant that McREL place all of the results through another evaluation that meet the NCLB criteria.
The study is to examine the characteristics and outcomes of school-based programs that are involved with the 21st Century programs, the evaluation addresses the usefulness of the funding resource of the 21st Century grant program and not the success of the after-school strategies. The National Institute on Out-of-School Time is concerned with development of the whole child.
Reference
Lauer, P. A., Akiba, M., Wilkerson, S. B., Apthorp, H. S., Snow, D., and Martin-Glenn, M. (2003) The effectiveness of out-of-school-time strategies in assisting low-achieving students in reading and mathematics: a research synthesis retrieved October 13, 2008 from http://www.missouri/~akibam/html/pdf/TheEffectiveness.pdf
Creswell, J. W. (2003) Research design qualitative, quantitative, and mixed methods approaches 2nd. Ed.